We’re going to do something a little wacky here. Today we’re talking about the best Xbox RPGs. Yes, that’s the original console. We aren’t talking about the Xbox 360, or Xbox One here. This is an unusual topic because it was not a console that was well known for having a large library of role playing games. It does however deserve credit for bringing Western style RPGs to the console market. That’s huge. We take it for granted now but it was not common practice at the time to have PC style role playing games on console. Now they’re everywhere. Alright that’s enough with the history lesson. Let’s get to the list. These are our picks for the Top 10 Best Xbox RPGs of all time!

#10. – Arx Fatalis
Never heard of this one before? You’re not alone. I myself only found it when deep diving into the Xbox’s library. Arx Fatalis was the first game developed by Arkane Studios. Starting to sound a little more familiar now? It’s a pretty traditional Western style RPG, but it has its twists. The first person point of view is nothing new, but how you interact with the world is. Rather than using the traditional dialogue trees and choices (which I’ve never been a fan of anyway) your actions instead do the talking. It is really impressive just how far this mechanic goes with consequences and new ways forward being opened. It’s all based on how you play the game.
That’s how Western style RPGs are meant to be played, right? Unfortunately it comes at the cost of linearity. There are many ways to approach any given situation. Despite this the world is rather small. You’re stuck underground for the entire game. Yes, this is one big dungeon crawler. This is both good and bad. For one thing at least the action based combat is front and center. Or stealth, if that’s how you choose to play. No judgement here. There’s no vast overworld to travel across and get lost in. That’s a plus in my book. For this type of game anyway. Unfortunately it means that the scenery is very similar start to finish. If you don’t mind the neverending drab visuals then Arx Fatalis might be worth a look.
#9. – Otogi: Myth of Demons
Back when From Software was a niche developer (the good old days) they released a miriad of different games on a variety of platforms. This was before they got stuck in the Souls cycle. This one is pretty action forward. For being an RPG and all, I mean. It’s a 3D hack and slash where it’s your job simply to slash through a variety of demons. Simple, right? At first glance Otogi: Myth of Demons doesn’t even look like an RPG. I assure you it is. As you defeat enemies you gain experience points and in turn level up. This increases your attack power, hit points, defense, etc. You also pick up money that lets you buy new equipment and magic. The RPG mechanics are basic, but I assure you they’re there.
So what makes this one so great? It’s the action. Otogi: Myth of Demons has a really rewarding combat system. The damage dealt is based on a neat combo system, and there’s a miriad of different spells as well. These can even be charged up. I really liked the aerial combat here. Gravity ain’t no thing apparently. You can stay in the air for an entirely unrealistic amount of time. As long as you’re hacking away at enemies that is. Otogi: Myth of Demons also has destructible environments. We take it for granted now, but back then this was new technology. It’s still fun to knock enemies into objects and watch them shatter into a million pieces. Combat isn’t particularly deep, nor does is the story great. Otogi: Myth of Demons is a basic, but fun time. Don’t let that fool you though. This one gets quite difficult later on.
#8. – Rent-a-Hero No. 1
You know what this list is lacking? Superhero games. Yeah, the concept doesn’t typically lend itself well to the RPG genre. Rent-A-Hero intended to change this. Unfortunately the game has a storied past. The original title was released on the Sega Genesis, then remade for the Dreamcast, and finally ported to the Xbox. The problem is no version was ever localized. This version came closest though with an incomplete translated prototype leaked. It’s incomplete, but playable. It’s also quite fun.
Rent-A-Hero is Sega at their best. What I mean is that it’s wacky, bizarre, and downright insane. It’s a 3D action RPG wherein you play as a teenager who, through hilarious circumstance winds up in a super hero suit on his birthday. Unfortunately it’s a rental. That means you have to pay for it by completing a variety of different weird missions around the city. It doesn’t make much sense, but it’s not supposed to. That’s the magic of Sega. Rent a Hero plays a bit like a beat em up. One with a heavy handed focus on RPG elements. The game is fun, charming, and you won’t ever forget it. That’s the sign of a classic role playing game.
#7. – The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
The Elder Scrolls series was a pretty big deal on PC in the 90s. Bethesda brought it to home consoles starting with the original Xbox. The first thing that should be said about this game is that it’s massive. The world is absolutely gigantic, and the amount of choice you’re given over how to play is vast. That’s kind of the draw of Western style RPGs. You could completely lose yourself in the character creation mechanic alone. This is important because your decisions here will affect how you play the game. At least in the beginning; it’s possible to focus on other areas as you progress, Unfortunately if you make a potato of a character in the beginning you’re gonna be cut into french fries. This game is not easy.
Did I mention this game is huge? I’m not just talking about the game world. That too is big, but where people get lost in Morrowind is in its side quests and the sheer number of options. You can kill almost any character. Yes, even those important to the story. You’ll be stuck forever, but hey, the option is there for masochists. You can play Morrowind in either first or third person perspective. The world is entirely 3D, and combat is action based. Your skills, stats and equipment determine how you’ll fare in battle. It’s basically dungeons and dragons in video game form. It’s also very easy to die. Sometimes simply wandering into the wrong side of town will spell your doom. The world is super interesting to explore, and everything is just so vast and detailed. This was the most impressive Xbox RPG in terms of scope and scale.
#6. – Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords
Star Wars fans are never satiated. They always want more. Obsidian gave them just that with a sequel to everyone’s favorite Star Wars RPG. In this case they decided to pick up the story five years from where the last one left us. I won’t spoil what happens, but the Jedi are not in a good state. As a matter of fact the character you create is the very last one. Supposedly. You are given a lot of options regarding how you want to play. This is through the character creation mechanic. What’s really cool is the fact that, unlike the first outing, you start out as a Jedi. This gives more interesting choices to make right out of the gate.
The combat system is largely unchanged from the original KOTOR. It’s a combination of real-time and turn based mechanics with dungeons and dragons style dice rolls happening in the background. You can freeze the action to issue commands to your characters, but for the most part battles kind of feel a bit like they’re on autoplay. There’s just enough control to keep things interesting however. KOTOR II also more options for battle. This includes things like new light saber forms, force powers, etc. You know, the good stuff. The game also feels less clunky as well. While KOTOR II is good I still prefer the original. What can I say?
#5. – Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
I’m about to say something that’s going to ruin my nerd cred. I’m not the biggest Star Wars fan. This was especially true around the time Knights of the Old Republic came out. I didn’t even like Star Wars back then. This game however is the reason I picked up the Xbox. Why? I blame it on FOMO. The game was killing it with critic reception. There was a lot of hype. I was sure it would be the best thing since sliced bread. Or, blue milk, if that’s your thing. Unfortunately I just didn’t like it. Over the years KOTOR has grown on me (as has Star Wars in general). That’s why it’s on this list.
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic is a turn based RPG. That’s pretty unusual for a Western style role playing game. The action briefly freezes when a battle starts. Then it’s on like Donkey Kong. You can enter commands, but combat moves a bit on autopilot. Oh and you can freely move around too. KOTOR features a variety of different weapons as well. You can get your pew pew on with laser guns, or whip around a light saber like you’re Obi Wan Kenobi. It’s up to you. The force powers however are the highlight. These are so elaborate they can completely change how you approach enemies. It’s a really in depth system. You even get a party of characters that mostly just make their own decisions. I just wish the dialogue trees were more interesting and not so black and white. The story also never gripped me.
#4. – Fable
Project Ego, yeah right! That was Fable’s codename during development, and believe you me when I say it was all hype. Peter Molyneux promised gamers a world they could directly affect nearly every aspect of. Unfortunately the delivery was a little off. Okay, so Fable was only a shell of what was promised. That’s okay because it was actually pretty fun. The game itself throws you into the world of Albion. It’s a 3D action RPG wherein you don’t create your own hero at the start. No. Instead you mold them into what you want them to be. How do you do this? By playing how you want to, of course.
What I mean is that if you want to be a strong warrior then face enemies head on with brute strength. If what you’re seeking is a stealthy archer then practice, and then practice some more. The same goes for those that want to rely on magic. Your actions affect your characters in a multitude of ways, but the highlight is the morality mechanics. You can go on a killing spring to rack up evil points, or try and save everyone to be an angel. It’s up to you. Sometimes it’s as simple as selecting a response from a dialogue tree. Combat itself is a lot of fun with some neat magic, and smooth melee combat. Unfortunately it doesn’t feel like you get to spend enough time in Fable to really affect the world that much. It’s over far too soon. Fable is cool, but it’s no Project Ego.
#3. – Sudeki
Haters gonna hate. Sudeki was met with lukewarm reception, and generally those that did play it don’t remember the game fondly. This game did manage to strike a chord with me. It’s not that Sudeki is amazing in any one area. It is however a well rounded and charming romp. This action RPG has you controlling four different characters that all excel in different areas. You can switch freely between them during battle. Two members of your party are the typical action RPG protagonists. They fight using melee attacks with which they can string together combos, block, and even dodge. Combat with them is fun, but the combo system is a little awkward, and controls are a bit stiff.
What’s interesting is that the other two characters fight enemies from a first person perspective. This is the Xbox, after all, and first person shooters were all the rage. These fighters shoot projectiles at foes. The change in gameplay style is really refreshing. Dare I say it’s great. In typical fashion you can customize the behaviors of your CPU controlled party members, and I really liked the options here. Overall Sudeki is charming, fun, and refreshing in that it doesn’t take itself too seriously. That art design though… woof. The mix of Japanese and Western style aesthetics just didn’t work here. In my opinion Sudeki was underrated. It’s one of the best Xbox RPGs in my opinion.
#2. – Jade Empire
KOTOR was good, but for my money, it was Jade Empire that really brought the heat. The game takes place in a fantasy world based on Asia and mythology. Right out of the gates the setting gripped me. The graphics are amazing even now, and really bring this world to life. What’s more is that it deviated from the dull color schemes games were leaning toward in this era. Jade Empire is bright and vibrant. Also, it has a far more intuitive and easy on the eyes interface than most Western style RPGs of this era. The story is pretty interesting as well. Jade Empire is the total package, but how does it play?
Really well actually. It’s unique in that Jade Empire’s combat system is based on martial arts. It ditches the battle system Bioware introduced in KOTOR and goes pure action for this outing. You string together attacks against foes using attacks based on real martial arts, and can even switch between several styles. Some of these are hand to hand while others throw weapons into the mix. Jade Empire’s combat is fast, and flows really well. It’s downright rewarding. In typical fashion Bioware brought the morality system back for this title, and it’s functionally similar to that in KOTOR. It’s not my favorite. The rest of the game is so good that I couldn’t even be bothered to care. If you’re going to play one Xbox RPG then you could do far worse.
#1. – Phantasy Star Online Episodes I & II
Phantasy Star Online was my jam. On the Dreamcast I spent hundreds of hours maxing out a mulitude of different characters both online and offline. Sega continued their RPG saga first on the Gamecube with an enhanced version which included nearly double the content. This was later ported to the Xbox. It only makes sense, right? I mean the Xbox offered by far the more intuitive online experience after all. The game was every bit as fun as it was on the Dreamcast. Even better, actually, because this version offers split screen multiplayer for those who can’t go online. It’s a good thing too because the servers have long been shut down.
Phantasy Star Online Episodes I & II deviates from the mainline franchise in numerous ways. Being able to play it over the internet is just one of these. First of all you begin by creating a character. There are multiple races to choose from, and a few different classes as well. After choosing their costume and naming your guy you are whisked away to the planet of Ragol to find out why a space colony was wiped out. Gameplay is purely action based with a rudimentary combat system, and decent sized environments to explore. There’s also a fair bit of content too, but generally you’ll be fighting your way through the same areas over and over again to gain experience and levels. It’s fun to go solo, but the game is best with three other buddies. This is easily the best Xbox RPG as far as I’m concerned.








