Home » Sega CD » Lunar: Eternal Blue Review (Sega CD, 1995)

Lunar: Eternal Blue Review (Sega CD, 1995)

A new era, and a new hero. One named Hiro, to be exact. Yeah that pun was probably intentional.

Listen, I know the Sega CD wasn’t great. It was expensive, had bad marketing, few games were released for it, and it came out at an awkward time. I know this. That doesn’t mean I don’t love it though. There’s something really charming about 16-bit titles on CD. I think it has something to do with developer’s not really knowing what to do with the format. A few managed to figure it out. RPGs. Now that’s the ticket. This genre was focused around storytelling and long quests. It’s just perfect for a high capacity storage medium. Lunar: The Silver Star is easily the top game on the platform. Heck, it’s one of the best RPGs of all time. It even had a sequel. Unfortunately, Lunar: Eternal Blue didn’t fare so well. Let’s dive in and check out why.

Admittedly, my first exposure to Lunar: Eternal Blue was the remake on the Sony PlayStation. That version is easily one of my favorite games of all time. The first time I played Eternal Blue on the Sega CD I expected to love it. Heck, the Sega CD version of the Silver Star is actually better than the PS1 remake. So what’s the deal then? Publisher Working Designs, for as much as I love them, made some bizarre changes to the game during localization. I can handle heightened difficulty and even reworking of some gameplay elements. That’s not what they did here. Well, at least that’s not the only changes they made. I’ll get into why their additions ruin this otherwise perfectly good video game a bit later.

Lunar: Eternal Blue takes place in the same world as the Silver Star. The setting is a planet primarily based around swords and sorcery. You know, the typical medieval anime schtick. There are however airships and other advanced technologies. They aren’t out of place because these elements are based on magic. See how it all ties together? The basic setting, the Silver Star, may be the same but some changes have been made to it. After all, Eternal Blue starts one thousand years after the conclusion of Dragonmaster Alex’s quest in the previous title.

The party explores the world map in Lunar: Eternal Blue.

The hero this time around is a young lad named Hiro. He’s a kind hearted soul, but a bit mischievous. He dreams of going on adventures and exploring ruins. Our protagonist lives with his adoptive grandfather Gwyn in a house near an ancient structure called the Blue Spire. One day an odd light comes beaming down from sky directly into these ruins. Hiro and Gwyn set out to find out just what it means. To their surprise they meet a young lady named Lucia inside. She is cold and with a single purpose; she wishes to find the Goddess Althena so that they can rid the world of the evil entity known as Zophar who is now threatening to destroy it.

So how exactly does Hiro get swept up into her quest? It all begins when the leader of Althena’s guard arrives on the scene. He has gotten word that a destroyer has come to the Silver Star to bring an end to civilization as they know it. Unfortunately he comes to believe this is Lucia herself. Hiro helps her escape, and eventually sets out on his own adventure to deliver the girl to the holy city of Pentagulia wherein she can complete her mission. As is typical in these types of games not everything is as it seems, and our budding hero has his work cut out for him. There’s many a plot twist to be discovered, and a fun cast of characters that join along the way.

The story is absolutely charming. It’s easy the plot as anime schlock. That’s not the case. The characters and world are incredibly memorable and quite distinct. Furthermore the fact that the story is a continuation is really cool too. There are a few returning faces, and several references. Eternal Blue is disconnected just enough though that knowledge of the Silver Star isn’t a pre-requisite. The plot is perfectly enjoyable as a self contained story. Understanding the references and seeing some of the same places though kicks it up to the next level. The game is also full of anime full motion video sequences and these are amazing. Especially for the hardware. I have zero complaints about the story. I couldn’t nitpick this plot even if I wanted to.

Hiro hunts for treasure in the opening full motion video sequence.

Lunar: Eternal Blue is a fairly traditional turn based RPG. It uses a top down perspective for exploration. You have a world map, towns, caves, dungeons etc. In many of these areas you’ll encounter enemies at random. Just by walking around. You know the drill. From here you’re whisked away to a side view screen with your party members typically on the right, and enemies on the left. All actions performed in battle are commands you select from a menu. Options include attacking with a weapon, casting magic spells/using special moves, using items, etc. You know, all the typical stuff. The game appears very traditional at first but Eternal Blue has some twists.

For one thing placement during these encounters is a major part of gameplay. Characters aren’t stuck standing still like in most RPGs. They move, a lot. Using short range weapons will cause your character to automatically run to the targeted enemy to strike. Thing is they have a limited movement range. Sometimes they won’t be able to get there. When they can no longer move their turn is up. Enemies are limited in the same manner. Some spells and special attacks cause splash damage. This means that any nearby foes (or allies, if you’re being attacked) will also take damage if they’re standing within range. The only issue is you can’t pick where you want everyone to stand. At least not in the heat of battle. Instead you have to plan things out based on the actions performed.

There’s also an emphasis here on multi-strikes. The battle system is cool like that. Each character has a stat which determines how many different attacks they can perform with the basic command. It differs with each party member, and your physical fighters will often have more than the mages. Obviously. What’s interesting is that if they defeat a foe and still have attacks left they’ll move on to the next closest one automatically. Provided they still have any movement left, that is.

The last thing worth mentioning in regards to the battle system is Ruby. She’s a talking baby fire dragon, and Hiro’s pet/companion. If you bring an enemy to near death status at the end of a turn she’ll swoop in and finish the job by scratching or blowing fire on them. She’s pretty weak and can only dole out a few points of damage, but it’s a neat feature nonetheless. At one point in the story she even gets a boost to her attack power, but by then she’s just not very useful.

Battles in Lunar: Eternal Blue are fun and engaging. There are enough unique features here to set it apart from the pack. It’s highly iterative from that of the Silver Star, but there’s more polish and options here. It’s a bit of a bummer that you never get to choose your party members though. People simply come and go with story events, and very few even join your adventure. The fact that you can have five total is amazing though.

A typical battle with a full party of characters.

Each of these characters has their own role in battle defined by their skills, range, etc. It’s fun to explore the options at your disposal. Who you have with you directly affects the way you approach each battle scenario. In particular I’m talking about the bosses. Unfortunately for the first branch of the quest one of these characters is pretty useless. I’m talking about Lucia. Gamearts did her dirty. She has very few spells, and automatically acts on her own. She’s also quite weak. Eventually she gets better, but by then gamers will no doubt be tired of the character. It’s a shame because the plot revolves around her.

Eternal Blue even uses an in depth skill system. Characters learn either magic or special moves for use in combat. Some can be used outside of it, such as healing spells for example. While they gain base skills from gaining levels these can be further powered up by using SP gained from battles. Not only does this improve the potency of the specific move in question, but can lead to learning additional ones. The game makes it so you never feel like you have enough of these points, and I found that they really encouraged me to grind. That’s not a problem for me because I grew up with this mechanic, but many are adverse to it.

Up to this point Lunar: Eternal Blue probably sounds like an amazing game. Right? Everything we’ve talked about is positive so far. So why the low rating? Working Designs tweaked a few things and the end result pretty much ruins the experience. For one thing you are limited on how often you can save your progress. It costs SP to do so. This means you will often have to choose between leveling up skills or saving your data. That to me is one of the strangest and most unintuitive mechanics in any video game, ever. This isn’t a ten hour survival horror game. It’s an RPG, and a difficult one at that. Punishing players for being meticulous so as not to lose their progress here is an absolutely bizarre decision that actually ruins the experience. What were they thinking?

Lucia makes her first appearance to Hiro and Ruby in an animated sequence early in the game.

Next up is the difficulty. Lunar: The Silver Star wasn’t a cakewalk, but it wasn’t overly difficult either. The gameplay was fair and balanced. That’s not the case here. The balancing is completely out of whack. There were sections of the game I cruised through only to hit a boss (Borgan is the perfect example of this) where I was completely outmatched. Instead of a gradual incline the difficulty instead is all peaks and valleys. I understand that this was used to combat the rental market, but it just makes Lunar: Eternal Blue feel entirely inconsistent. Again, terrible decisions were made during localization.

It’s a real shame too because Lunar: Eternal Blue is a very special RPG. The storytelling is truly beyond that of any role playing game of its era, and the production values are through the roof. I can’t think of a more charming 16-bit adventure than this one. Furthermore the battle system is well designed with interesting mechanics that are unlike anything else of this era. It really goes to show that a few boneheaded decisions that seem insignificant can really ruin an experience.

Let’s get to more of the good stuff now. The graphics are really good. Lunar: Eternal Blue looks absolutely amazing with meticulous tile based scenery that looks great. I was especially impressed with animated elements in the environments. Easily the best part of the visuals however are the full motion videos. By now we all have come to expect grainy or low detail animations on the platform. Lunar: Eternal Blue’s full motion video looks incredible in comparison. Almost like something we would see on the Sega Saturn or Sony PlayStation. The soundtrack is equally as impressive. It’s streamed entirely from the disc via redbook audio. It sounds fantastic, and the game has some of the best compositions of all time in it. Overall the graphics and soundtrack are great, and truly push the Sega CD past what anyone thought it was capable of.

Summary
I can't begin to express how disappointed I was with this version of the game. Had Working Designs left things alone and just translated the text this would easily be an upper 9 rated game. With these changes Eternal Blue on the Sega CD is most certainly not that. It's surprising because Working Designs always did their fans such a solid. They really didn't come through here. Thankfully they learned their lesson by the time the remake came out, and delivered us a solid version of Lunar: Eternal Blue on the Sony PlayStation. The Sega CD version though? Skip it.
Good
  • Charming Graphics and Soundtrack
  • Fantastic and Memorable Story
  • Super High Quality Full Motion Video for the Sega CD
  • Fun Battle System
  • Great Dungeon Designs
Bad
  • Completely Unbalanced Due to Localization Changes
5.8
Poor
Written by
Lifelong gamer and movie addict. I started playing with the original Nintendo but quickly fell in love with the arcades as well! It was the SNES that really cemented this as a long term hobby and the rest is history! I'm a former writer at the website Epinions.com and started this blog as a response to that closing down. I have a lot of retro video game knowledge and wanted to share it. That's where you all come in!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>