With Halloween fast approaching I’ve decided to write about a subject near and dear to my heart. Horror RPGs. In this day and age they’re pretty rare. There was a specific point in time when developers decided to mix their horror with their traditional role playing adventure together. The results were often uneven, but it was usually a good time regardless. Some of these games however are bonafide classics. In tribute to this forgotten blend we’re going to highlight the Top 10 Best Horror RPGs of all time, and it’s just in time for Halloween. The best holiday. Not all of them are spooky and creepy. Some are good picks for Halloween. Let’s get cookin.

#10. – Shadow Hearts
There’s no way around. The first Shadow Hearts is a little rough around the edges. This was an early RPG release on the PS2, and it shows. Also working against it is the fact that Shadow Hearts is the follow up to the PS1 role playing game Koudelka. That game was terrible. This one is just okay. One of the most interesting aspects of the game is that it takes place in an alternate version of the real world. In the early 1900s. Of course everything is anime head to toe. Oh, Japan. The plot follows a rude hero (hey that’s their words, not mine) who sets off on a dark gothic adventure to escort a mysterious girl to Shanghai. Why? Because the voices in his head tell him to. Yeah, Yuri (as we come to discover is his name) is a bit unstable.
He’s also a surprisingly cool protagonist. You see, the guy can transform into monsters. Combat at first looks traditional but Shadow Hearts kind of does its own thing. Battles are turn based with the typical commands like attack, special, magic, etc. When striking a foe you first must contend with what’s called the Judgement Ring. You have to time button presses in conjunction with a swirling hand around it. If you stop it on a colored surface then the attack is stronger. This is a neat concept that was more fully realized in the sequels. It’s still pretty cool here. Shadow Hearts isn’t jump out of your seat scary, but the oppressive atmosphere, dark environments and crazy monster designs pull their weight plenty.
#9. – The 3rd Birthday
Fans were overjoyed when Square-Enix finally announced another installment in the Parasite Eve series. They were less enthusiastic when we all finally saw it. The 3rd Birthday moved the franchise even further from its RPG roots. Make no mistake. The mechanics are still there. It’s just this time Ava’s exploits more closely resembled a third person shooter. Bummer. As everyone’s favorite blonde haired NYPD officer you run through several 3D environments. The gameplay loop consists of firing weapons from an over the shoulder view. In a rather odd move the game no longer centers around mitochondrial monsters. Instead the threat is a race of reality-warping monsters called the Twisted. Lame.
Hey at least this time we don’t have to endlessly hear about mitochondria. That was always kind of grating. The 3rd Birthday ditches exploration based gameplay of the previous two titles. Now there’s a strict mission based structure with specific objectives. Unfortunately the gameplay does not feel like Parasite Eve. At all. At least the gunplay is good, and Aya moves fluidly during combat sequences. The RPG elements are the highlight though. Between missions you can purchase parts and upgrade your weapons. The same can be done with your armor. This is done with battle points that are earned for defeating the Twisted and completing missions. I really enjoyed playing around with this mechanic. It may be a poor excuse for a Parasite Eve game, but the 3rd Birthday is still a fun horror RPG. It’s just barely a role playing game.
#8. – Fragile Dreams: Farewell Ruins of the Moon
Now it’s time for a change of pace. Fragile Dreams is the only Wii game on this list, and it’s quite different from the others. For one thing the horror elements are rather light. Instead Fragile Dreams focuses on being an adventure game. It does that pretty well too. There is however an oppressive, lonely, and melancholic atmosphere in this world. It qualifies for this list. Here you play as a youth named Seto. He’s tasked with traversing the ruins of a destroyed Tokyo, and fighting against the ghosts that inhabit it. It’s not as spooky as it sounds. This one is a little more lighthearted than you might expect. It has a pleasant colorful atmosphere and soft anime stylings.
Yes, you fight ghosts, but come on. That alone isn’t really scary, is it? In this case the horror elements come from the eerie and lonely atmosphere. It’s incredible foreboding. The game features dark graphics, and most of the time areas are illuminated by just Seto’s flashlight. This is highly immersive thanks to how it’s integrated with the Wii remote’s pointer controls. Actual combat is not all that common. Enemies are rare encounters. The battle system is action based with Seto striking foes with whatever weapon he has equipped. Sometimes they start out invisible and he has to reveal their locations using the handy dandy flashlight. How’s that for a mouseketool? Unfortunately these ghosts aren’t going to scare you. The dark and foreboding environments might though. Fragile Dreams will make you feel completely alone. It’s amazing in that way.
#7. Parasite Eve II
Parasite Eve 2 is not as good as the original. Why? Squaresoft ditched the more traditional RPG gameplay and instead focused on survival horror. This game is basically Resident Evil with stats. Oh and equipment too. You still control Aya, and once more she’s a force to be reckoned with. This time the action is removed from the cityscape of Manhattan, and you’re in some military facility in the Southwest. The desert, specifically. The change in setting is actually really interesting in terms of the overarching story. The monsters you face are still based on mitochondria, as are Aya’s special abilities. She just forgot everything between the first and second games. How convenient, right?
The first thing you have to get used to when coming in is the controls. Like I said, this one is like Resident Evil. That means Aya controls like a tank. Up means forward in the direction she’s facing, and the horizontal inputs simply turn her. All damage and stats are still numerical. Honestly this is just as awkward as it’s always been. Parasite Eve II looks and moves like a survival horror game. It’s a shame that the RPG elements take a backseat. You still have a lot of roleplaying to do here. There’s a lot to manage in this game. Much moreso than your common Resident Evil or Silent Hill. Perhaps it’s this blend in genres that makes Parasite Eve II so good. I just wish it had more jump scares, or RPG elements. For goodness sake it should have committed more to either genre.
#6. – Costume Quest
For this one we’re trading in scary and spooky for good old fashioned Halloween fun. That’s precisely what Costume Quest is. It represents the innocence of childhood imagination, and the atmosphere of the holiday. The game does this perfectly. Honestly I can’t think of any other game that so perfectly encapsulates the spirit of Halloween. I suppose that’s the point. Right? Costume Quest was a simple downloadable game, but I’ve never played anything else that hits these points so well. It’s very short, but in the end you’ll feel like a kid again, and on Halloween at that. It’s just what we’ve always wanted. Plus, how many other games let you go trick or treating? None!
In Costume Quest you play as either a boy or girl. It’s Halloween night, and there’s candy out there ripe for the treating. Unfortunately the character’s sibling is kidnapped by ugly monsters called grubbins, and it’s up to you to rescue them. Battles are strictly turn based, and rely on timing for effective strikes. Oh and did I mention that your character transforms into an avatar of the costume they’re wearing during combat? That’s pretty important. You can even change costumes, and this functions kind of like a classic job system. The game has a wonderful abstract art style. Additionally there are a few mini-games to participate in like bobbing for apples as well as hide and seek. You know, to get you into the spooky spirit. Costume Quest might not be scary or even eerie, but it will get you in the Halloween spirit.
#5. – Okage: Shadow King
Here’s another one that’s a bit light on the spooky. That’s okay because it still feels like Halloween. Okage: Shadow King is another early role playing game for the PlayStation 2. This one circumvents traditional horror in favor of the bizarre. It is stylized like a classic Tim Burton film. Think Nightmare Before Christmas. That means characters are a bit abstract in proportions, and enemies are creepy and crazy in some unsettling ways. The plot and setting lean more into comedy than anything else though. The story follows the revival of a shadow king, and his quest to regain his lost powers. How does he intend to do this? By defeating other shadow kings, of course. He inhabits the soul of a teenager named Ari, and the two venture together to complete this off-beat quest.
Despite the bizarro approach here Okage: Shadow King is actually pretty traditional in execution. You wander around various 3D environments, and can see enemies on the map before battle. When you touch them you’re whisked to a separate screen, and from here everything is turn based. The battle system is pretty typical, but I liked it’s nuances. Characters can each attack, have special abilities. The game takes a note from Final Fantasy by using the active time battle system, but it waits for you while commands are input. It’s clean, functional, and fun. That’s all I really care about. Okage: Shadow King is pretty light on horror elements, but the game is a bizarre and fun time. It’s the art style that makes this one such a great pick for Halloween play.
#4. – Parasite Eve
In contrast we have Parasite Eve. This one is straight up horror. It came out in Squaresoft’s experimental age, and at a time when Resident Evil was the new hotness. They thought combining this new genre with the RPG genre would be a hit. They were right. Parasite Eve has you play as NYPD officer Aya Brea. The story begins when chaos breaks out at an opera she’s attending. Everyone begins bursting into flames from the demonic songstress’ singing. Somehow she’s immune. Mitochondria or something. Who cares. At first glance the game looks like Resident Evil. It sure doesn’t play like it though.
You’ll spend most of your time wandering pre-rendered backgrounds. Aya and other characters are modeled in 3D. The style feels a little restrictive, but it holds up pretty well. Battles occur randomly, and the execution is very unique. The game uses the classic ATB system where Aya can only act when a meter charges. What’s interesting is that you can move around in real-time. You’ll need to do so in order to dodge attacks. Aya can use both firearms and melee weapons, but the former is limited by ammunition. That’s one way it’s like Resident Evil. As you progress this becomes less of an issue. Ammo drops become commonplace. The limitations still add to the sense of dread though. Parasite Eve has a dark story, and a fun battle system. It’s not only one of the greatest horror games of all time, but also one of the best RPGs overall.
#3. – Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
This was the breakout hit in the Shin Megami Tensei series. Yes, there were two Persona games before it. These went mostly ignored. They aren’t that good. With Persona 3 the developers hit perfect blend of social aspects and galavanting RPG just right. Oh and this is a horror game. Much moreso than the Persona games that followed it. There’s a dark blue and gray anime aesthetic in play here, and the enemies you face are demons. There’s only a single dungeon in the game, but it’s a dark looming tower with over two hundred and sixty floors. Oh and most areas here are randomly generated. Spooky happenings are sure to ensue, but at least you’ve got a colorful cast of anime characters to hold your hand through it all.
So what makes Persona 3 unique? You’re a student in a school, and that’s where you spend your days. Completing schoolwork and hanging out with friends are your primary tasks here. Don’t worry. You’re not actually doing schoolwork. That would be lame. It is here that you can interact with characters to build social links, and these help you out both in battle and to acquire additional Personas/items. When night hits you’re off to the tower of Tartarus wherein demons lie in wait. The battle system is pretty traditional at least in terms of the overarching Shin Megami Tensei series. Action is turn based, with your primary command being to attack. Magic is used via the character’s attached Persona. You can even change around which one your main character is using. It’s a really cool game that everyone is no doubt tired of hearing about.
#2. – Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Okay so the first Shadow Hearts was a rough start for the series. It was very basic and kind of weird. Covenant is where the franchise really hit its stride. Right away I liked that this story picks up where the last one left off. Six months later, of course. You once again play as Yuri, but now the story revolves around the events of World War I. Of course it’s a bizarro version of reality. Monsters and demons are running rampant. Plus everyone is an anime character. Shadow Hearts: Covenant functions as a horror RPG thanks to it’s gothic and dark architecture as well as its oppressive setting. The crazy monster designs also help. It’s not scary or anything, but the game is a far cry from happy go lucky. That’s for sure.
Combat is once again turn based, but some changes have been made. The Judgement Ring is back. If you liked it you’ll be happy with the new upgrades. For those who didn’t there’s a new auto ring mode. This means you don’t have to meddle with it. It’s the best of both worlds. You can now customize and use different rings which have a variety of effects. The way this is handled makes the mechanic infinitely more interesting. Battles flow significantly better here. They’re actually fun which is not something I could always say about the predecessor. The sheer amount of new options you’re given is staggering. There’s even another slot for an additional party member. Shadow Hearts: Covenant is an upgrade in almost every way. Did I mention the story is surprisingly good too?
#1. – Sweet Home
As if the number one spot could have been anything else. Sweet Home hits all the right notes. Traditional RPG? Check. Survival horror focus? Heck yes. Scary? Surprisingly, yes. This is a freaking NES game. It has no business checking most, and especially not all of these boxes. Remember, survival horror as a genre didn’t even exist yet. Sweet Home was a trailblazer. It’s what Resident Evil’s director Shinji Mikami claims he based Resident Evil on. The blueprint is obvious. Sweet Home might look and quack like something similar to Final Fantasy, but it sure isn’t that. Not by a long shot.
Unlike most RPGs Sweet Home has just one setting. The Mamiya Mansion. You play as a team of documentary filmmakers (of which there are five) who intend to get to the bottom of its mysteries. The door locks behind them, and they’re taunted by the ghost of the lady of the manor. It’s up to them to solve puzzles, battle fiendish ghouls and hopefully survive the night. Battles are turn based with parties of up to three characters. If someone dies they’re gone forever. No phoenix downs. You must split the protagonists into multiple groups. Thing is they all have a unique item. This is where the puzzle solving comes in to play. You must pick and choose who to bring, and where to take them. The atmosphere here is oppressive. You have limited items, and never feel comfortable or set in this game. Sweet Home is amazing, but diabolical.








